Cavanaugh Capital Management Specializing in Active Fixed Income and Passive Equity Strategies
 

The 2000s - The Times That Tried Investors' Souls
December 31, 2009
By: Taylor Graff, Senior Associate

Story #1 – Financial Crisis Rocks Wall Street

After the stock market bubble burst, investors turned to other asset classes such as commodities, credit and real estate which all performed very well from 2003-2006.  The positive sentiment in credit and real estate, along with historically low interest rates, created a boom in residential housing.  But by 2006, the boom became a bubble as mortgage underwriting standards loosened and securitization led to an immense investor appetite which allowed more mortgage loans to be made.

The bubble burst in 2007 as sub-prime mortgage defaults skyrocketed, home sales tumbled and residential housing prices fell.  Large brokerages all over the world were announcing billions of dollars in write-downs on sub-prime mortgage-related assets.  Soon the contagion spread to all sorts of securitized assets:  Collateralized Debt Obligations (CDOs), Structured Investment Vehicles (SIVs), Home-Equity Loan Asset-Backed Securities (ABS) (returns shown below) and many others. 

Home Equity Return ABS Cumm. Return

Some of these assets had been rated AAA, supposedly signifying that they were exceedingly safe investments.  By the end of 2007, many were worthless.  With uncertainty surrounding so many of these assets, people questioned the validity of financial statements coming out of Wall Street.  Exacerbating the problem, the credit market had deteriorated making cash very expensive.  The question became, without easy access to credit and uncertain asset valuations, how can investors know these brokerages are even solvent?

On March 14, 2008, this question led to a run on the bank at Bear Stearns.  Within days, the 85 year old Wall Street firm went from a brokerage giant to insolvent.  The stock dropped from $57 on Thursday, March 13 to $3 on Monday, March 17.  To save Bear from bankruptcy, the Federal Reserve organized an acquisition by J.P. Morgan.

For a time, it looked like the Federal Reserve had re-instilled confidence in the financial system; equity and credit markets rallied significantly after the panic surrounding Bear Stearns was quelled.  However, policymakers could not do anything to ease the collapsing housing market.  The negative cycle continued – rising mortgage defaults and falling home prices caused Wall Street losses to keep mounting. 

By September, solvency questions started being asked about another storied Wall Street firm – Lehman Brothers.  Various acquisition scenarios were whispered throughout the market but a deal could never be reached because there were too many questions surrounding Lehman’s assets and liabilities.  On September 14, it became clear Lehman Brothers would default.  Merrill Lynch, realizing that they would be the next domino to fall, agreed to a purchase by Bank of America.  Over the next few months, several more of America’s most prolific companies would be forced into a merger, rescued by the government or declare bankruptcy – AIG, Washington Mutual, Wachovia, Citigroup, Bank of America, Chrysler and General Motors.

When the dust settled it was America’s greatest financial crisis since the Great Depression.  From 10/9/07 to 3/9/09, the stock market dropped 58% making it the largest bear market since 1930’s. 

But beginning in March 2009, the market did turn.  It was boosted by several large banks who reported profits in the first quarter of 2009.  Asset write-downs were finally shrinking and the housing market was at least stabilizing.  In April and May, the Federal Reserve performed stress tests on all the “systemically important” banks.  The results were much better than expected and helped restore confidence in financial markets.

Next ...Technology Bubble Bursts

Timeline of Events

2000
10-Jan AOL acquires Time Warner
10-Mar Nasdaq peaks at 5,132 marketing the height of the Tech Bubble
3-Apr Microsoft declared a monopoly in Federal Court
18-May Boo.com declares bankruptcy
6-Nov Pets.com declares bankruptcy
7-Nov Voters go to the polls in the historically close election of 2000
12-Dec Supreme Court rules in Bush v. Gore, resulting in Bush's victory
2001
3-Jan Federal Reserve unexpectedly cuts key interest rates for the first time since 1998
31-Mar 1Q GDP report shows first decline in GDP since 1991
11-Sep Terrorist attacks cause financial market freefall
7-Oct U.S. led forces invade Afghanistan
22-Oct Enron acknowledges SEC investigation into its accounting practices
15-Nov Oil falls to $17.45 a barrel, the low point for the decade
2-Dec Enron declares bankruptcy
2002
3-Jun Dennis Kozlowski resigns as CEO of Tyco amidst a tax and accounting scandal
26-Jun SEC launches investigation into WorldCom's accounting practices
12-Jul WorldCom declares bankruptcy
10-Oct S&P 500 bottoms at 768.63, 51% below its all-time high set in 2000
2003
20-Mar U.S. Led forces invade Iraq
2004
30-Jun Federal Reserve raise key interest rate
1-Oct Oil officially closes above $50/barrel
2-Nov President George W. Bush wins reelection, defeating Senator John Kerry
2005
29-Aug Hurricane Katrina makes landfall; oil and gasoline prices skyrocket
17-Oct Refco declares bankruptcy
2006
1-Feb Ben Bernanke takes over as Chairman of the Federal Reserve
2007
27-Feb Dow Jones Industrial Average drops 400 points (largest drop since 9/11/2001) after HSBC announces significant write-downs on its sub-prime mortgage holdings
2-Apr Sub-prime mortgage giant, New Century, files for bankruptcy
16-Jul Bear Sterns announces that two sub-prime mortgage hedge funds had collapsed
10-Aug Central banks around the world inject liquidity in response to the financial crisis
16-Aug Countrywide takes out an emergency $11 billion loan
11-Oct S&P 500 peaks at 1,576.09
7-Nov New York District Attorney, Andrew Cuomo, announces investigation into Washington Mutual's mortgage practices
2008
3-Jan Crude oil trades above $100/barrel for the first time
11-Jan Bank of America purchases Countrywide Financial
7-Feb Auction Rate Security (ARS) crisis begins
16-Mar Bear Sterns is purchased by J.P. Morgan in a deal orchestrated by the Federal Reserve to avoid Bear's bankruptcy
11-Jul IndyMac is seized by the FDIC
7-Sep Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are placed in conservatorship by the Federal Government
14-Sep Bank of America purchases a distressed Merrill Lynch
15-Sep Lehman Brothers declares bankruptcy
17-Sep Federal Reserve lends AIG $85 billion to avoid bankruptcy
25-Sep Washington Mutual is seized by FDIC
29-Sep Dow Jones Industrial Average drop 777 points, the largest decline in its history as the House votes down the Economic Stabilization Act
3-Oct Wells Fargo and distressed Wachovia announce a merger
3-Oct House passes Economic Stabilization Act and President Bush signs it into law
9-Oct Icelandic banking system and currency collapses
13-Oct Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS), HBOS, and Lloyds are rescued by British government
14-Oct

U.S. Treasury uses TARP to purchase equity in nine of the nation's largest banks

4-Nov Senator Barack Obama is elected President of the United States, defeating Senator John McCain and becoming the nation's first African-American President
23-Nov Citigroup receives an additional $20 billion from U.S. Treasury
11-Dec FBI arrests Bernie Madoff for an alleged $50 billion ponzi scheme
19-Dec President Bush announces that U.S. Treasury will provide a bridge-loan to GM and Chrysler
2009
16-Jan Bank of America receives an additional $20 billion from U.S. Treasury
17-Feb President Obama signs 2009 Stimulus Bill
9-Mar S&P 500 bottoms at 666.79, a 12-year low and 58% below its 2007 peak, the largest drop since the Great Depression
30-Apr Chrysler files for bankruptcy and announces alliance with Fiat
7-May Federal Reserve releases the findings of its "stress tests" on bank capital showing better than expected results
1-Jun GM files for bankruptcy
10-Jun U.S. Treasury accepts first repayments from 10 banks in the TARP program
1-Nov CIT group declares bankruptcy
25-Nov Dubai World announces need to restructure debt or risk default
31-Dec S&P 500 finishes 2009 with a 23.5% gain, up 71.8% from the March low